Illinois Appellate Court Finds Testimony Regarding Plaintiff’s Lack of Health Insurance Admissible

Home » Blog » Car Accidents » Illinois Appellate Court Finds Testimony Regarding Plaintiff’s Lack of Health Insurance Admissible

In the Illinois Appellate case of Vanoosting v. Sellars, the Appellate Court held that the trial court incorrectly excluded Plaintiff’s testimony that she would have sought more medical treatment in the years following the accident if she had medical insurance, but that she could not afford the treatment she desired. 2012 IL App. (5th) 110365.

The case involved a straight-forward motor vehicle accident where the Defendant rear-ended the Plaintiff. The Plaintiff suffered injuries to her neck and back. Plaintiff’s medical bills at the time of trial totaled $18,286.46; however, the Plaintiff did not seek any medical treatment in the three years prior to trial. The Plaintiff sought to introduce evidence that she made $200 per week and did not have health insurance to explain why she didn’t seek medical treatment in the years preceding the trial, despite testifying that she continued to experience pain. The Plaintiff argued this evidence was relevant to show that she would have sought substantially more treatment had she had the financial means. The trial court barred Plaintiff’s testimony on this matter and the case went to trial. While the Plaintiff recovered $30,286.46 – constituting $18,286.46 for medical expenses and $12,000.00 for pain and suffering – the Plaintiff appealed.

The Illinois Appellate Court reversed the trial court’s exclusion of Plaintiff’s testimony regarding her lack of health insurance. The Court reasoned that the testimony was absolutely relevant pursuant to Illinois Rule of Evidence 401, as the testimony had a “tendency to make the existence of any fact that is of consequence to the determination of the action more probable or less probable that it would be without the evidence.”

The Appellate Court then determined that it was not unduly prejudicial for the jury to hear Plaintiff’s testimony that she did not have health insurance. The court reached this conclusion largely because the Defendant’s attorneys incessantly reminded the jury that the Plaintiff had undergone no medical treatment in the three years prior to the trial in an attempt to reduce her pain and suffering recovery.

If you or a loved one has been injured, contact The Kryder Law Group, LLC for your free consultation.

Health Insurance Coverage and Car Accidents

Generally, your auto insurance policy will cover medical expenses after you have exhausted your medical coverage. If the other driver is found to be at fault, the other driver’s auto insurance policy should be responsible for medical expenses. To seek reimbursement, you would have to submit bills to the insurance company directly. The healthcare system in the United States is fairly complicated, as some medical providers charge higher rates or will not provide care at all to patients who do not have comprehensive medical insurance. This can make it more difficult to determine access and costs for medical care that is needed to recover from your injuries.

What Does the Appeal Process Look Like

As this legal case illustrates, losing a court case does not necessarily mean that the case is over forever. You have the option of appealing a circuit court decision by submitting an appeal to the appellate court. The process of appealing a court decision looks a little different than the original trial. You will not receive a new trial, but rather the court will look to see what exactly happened at the circuit court level.

If you’re unable to successfully appeal through the appellate court, you could choose to bring your case through the Illinois Supreme Court. However, the Illinois Supreme Court only hears a small fraction of cases that are submitted to it each year. It is not obligated to review your case. Most successful appeals take place at the appellate court level. Depending on the nature of your case, your lawyer might recommend that you continue to see through the appeal process at the state supreme court.

Illinois Appellate Court Finds Testimony Regarding Plaintiff’s Lack of Health Insurance Admissible
blog illinois appellate court finds testimony regarding plaintiffs lack of health insurance admissible

Do I have a case?

    Phone Number (312) 598-1012
    134 North LaSalle St., Suite 1515
    Chicago, Illinois 60602 Get Directions

    Settlements & Verdicts

    $7.5 Million Recovered for a Construction Worker Injured on Site
    $3 Million Recovered for the Family of a Person Struck by a Garbage Truck
    $2.2 Million Recovered for a Salesperson Injured in an Automobile Collision
    $2 Million Recovered for a Person Struck by a Speeding Vehicle While Waiting for the CTA Bus
    $1.4 Million Recovered for a Computer Programmer Injured in a Slip and Fall
    Phone (312) 223-1700